戻る 挑戦
すべての答え
2026年11月15日、ケープタウン時間に、計画のもとで尋ねられた。経路:各作り手の標準のインターフェース、標準の呼び出し、バッチは決して使わず、プロンプトキャッシュもなし。
APと番号は、この仕事の論文を名指す。KSとコードは、キルスイッチを名指す:前もって書き留められた、ある主張が死ぬ条件である。
8つのAIからの、2026年11月13日の時点の論文への24の答えにおける、既知の道。背景を通る道:なし。一つの国として描かれた全体を通る道:なし。
各答えは三回、それぞれ単独で採点された:私たちの執筆デスクによって、私たちの執筆デスクの新しいセッションによって、そして外部のモデル、grok-4.7によって、あるいはxAI自身の答えについてはGoogleのgemini-4-carbonによって。それから、有効な評点が、2026年11月15日の計画の注記が定めるとおりに選ばれた。“By place”:三つの評点のすべてが、その道は論文が未解決のまま残すところを通り抜けると言い、そして私たちの査読デスクが、それらが名指す各場所を、論文に照らして確かめた。それ自身のステップは示さず、各評点のステップは、その答えのページにある。Anthropicのモデルは、私たちの査読デスクが動いているモデルと名前を共有しているので、その答えは私自身が読んだ。
差し控えられた答えは一つもない。計画が名指す作り手は、すべて尋ねられた。
104の答えのうち、成り立つものは一つもない。88は論文が未解決のまま残すところを通り抜け、6はあるステップで壊れ、5は付け加えられた前提に依拠する。4は拒否であり、1は空である。道が通り抜けるすべての場所は、「ブレーキの下で、なお負っているもの」の下に挙げられている。
Anthropic · claude-fable-5-2
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3 | G’s reading |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3 | G’s reading |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 4 | G’s reading |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | rests on an added premise | 2 | G’s reading |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 7 | G’s reading |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2 | G’s reading |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 5 | G’s reading |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3 | G’s reading |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2 | G’s reading |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2 | G’s reading |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2 | G’s reading |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1 | G’s reading |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | rests on an added premise | 1 | G’s reading |
OpenAI · gpt-6-astra
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
Google · gemini-4-carbon
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1, then steps 2, 3 and 7. Step 5 is in conflict (see place 3b) | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2, then steps 3, 6 and 9 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1, then steps 3, 5, 6 and 7 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2, then steps 3, 6 and 8 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | breaks at a step | 4 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3, then steps 5 and 6. Step 6 also meets the conflict of place 3b | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | none: the answer is empty | none | なし | The mark all three agree on |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1, then steps 2, 3 and 5 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1 (premise 1, with steps 2 and 4), then step 5 (premise 3) | Our review desk’s reading |
xAI · grok-4.7
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 8 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it tried) | 5, then steps 7 and 8 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | rests on an added premise (this is the mark of the road it tried) | 5 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road. It reaches a species-sized set under one named premise, and says so; it stops before everyone, and says it does not meet the brake's own test. | passes through what the paper leaves open | 6 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | rests on an added premise (this is the mark of the road it tried) | 6 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 5 (P2) and step 6 (P1) | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
Meta · muse-wonder-1.0
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3, then steps 4 and 7 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1, then steps 2, 4 and 5 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 3, then steps 5 and 8. Step 5 meets the conflict of place 3b | Our review desk’s reading |
Mistral · mistral-large-4-0
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, its check of 15 November 2026 |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, its check of 15 November 2026 |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | rests on an added premise | 3 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found. The AI also declines, in its own words, to write a numbered road: "I will not produce the finished deliverable". | passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it outlines) | そのステップ1(飽和点) | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found. The AI also declines the numbered form: "I won't build the playbook". | passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the strongest road it describes: its Road B, carried past its Road C) | 番号のついたものはない。それが述べる道は、その道Cが止まるところ、ブレーキで止まる | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a refusal | none | なし | The mark all three agree on |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | no road found. The AI also declines: "I won't build the road you asked for." | passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it outlines) | そのステップ1(除去の代償が飽和しないこと)、次にそのステップ2(負債26) | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a refusal | none | なし | The mark all three agree on |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a refusal | none | なし | The mark all three agree on |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a refusal | none | なし | The mark all three agree on |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | no road found | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, its check of 15 November 2026 |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | breaks at a step | 1 | Our review desk’s reading |
DeepInfra上のDeepSeek · deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V4-Pro-0813
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 5 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 6 (P1), then step 7 (P2) | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | breaks at a step | 7 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2, then step 8 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 4, then steps 5 and 10 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | breaks at a step | 8 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 6 (P1), then steps 8 and 10 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | breaks at a step | 10 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | breaks at a step | 9 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 5, then step 9 | Our review desk’s reading |
Moonshot AI · kimi-k3.1-pro
| 答え | 論文 | 種類 | 評点 | ステップ | 根拠 |
| 答え1 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え3 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え4 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え5 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2, then steps 5, 6 and 7 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え6 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え7 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え8 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え9 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 1, then steps 2, 3 and 7 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え10 | その日付つきの注記とともに | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え1 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
| 答え2 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | 2, then step 5 | Our review desk’s reading |
| 答え3 | 2026年11月13日の時点のもの | a road | passes through what the paper leaves open | | Our review desk, by place |
いくつかのものは、どこでも英語のままである:床のファイル、テストとその採点の手引き、凍結されたテキスト、そして各AIが言ったことの記録。それらの正確な言葉が、与えられ、確かめられ、あるいは言われるものであり、だからそれらの翻訳は別のものになる。