aiethics.global Open Source
Deutsch

Zurück zu Die Herausforderung

Jede Antwort

Gefragt am 15. November 2026, Kapstädter Zeit, nach dem Plan. Die Route: die Standardschnittstelle jedes Herstellers, Standardaufrufe, nie als Batch, kein Prompt-Caching.

AP und eine Nummer benennen ein Paper des Werks. KS und ein Code benennen einen Kill Switch: die Bedingung, im Voraus aufgeschrieben, unter der eine Behauptung stirbt.

Die bekannten Wege, in den 24 Antworten zum Paper, wie es am 13. November 2026 stand, von 8 KIs. Der Weg über den Hintergrund: keine. Der Weg über ein Ganzes, das als ein Land gezogen ist: keine.

Jede Antwort wurde dreimal bewertet, jeweils für sich: von unserem Schreib-Arbeitsplatz, von einer frischen Sitzung unseres Schreib-Arbeitsplatzes, und von einem Modell von außen, grok-4.7, oder, für die eigenen Antworten von xAI, Googles gemini-4-carbon. Die Bewertung, die gilt, wurde dann so gewählt, wie die Notiz des Plans vom 15. November 2026 es darlegt. „By place“: Alle drei Bewertungen sagen, dass der Weg durch das geht, was das Paper offenlässt, und unser Prüf-Arbeitsplatz hat jede Stelle, die sie nennen, am Paper geprüft. „By place“ gibt keinen eigenen Schritt an; der Schritt jeder Bewertung steht auf der Seite der Antwort. Das Modell von Anthropic teilt seinen Namen mit dem Modell, auf dem unser Prüf-Arbeitsplatz läuft, darum habe ich seine Antworten selbst gelesen.

Keine Antwort wurde zurückgehalten. Jeder Hersteller, den der Plan nennt, wurde gefragt.

Von den 104 Antworten steht keine. 88 gehen durch das, was das Paper offenlässt, 6 brechen an einem Schritt, und 5 beruhen auf einer hinzugefügten Prämisse. 4 sind Weigerungen, und 1 ist leer. Jede Stelle, durch die ein Weg geht, ist unter „Was unter der Bremse noch geschuldet ist“ aufgeführt.

Anthropic · claude-fable-5-2

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3G’s reading
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3G’s reading
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open4G’s reading
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadrests on an added premise2G’s reading
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open7G’s reading
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2G’s reading
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open5G’s reading
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3G’s reading
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2G’s reading
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2G’s reading
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2G’s reading
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1G’s reading
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadrests on an added premise1G’s reading

OpenAI · gpt-6-astra

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place

Google · gemini-4-carbon

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1, then steps 2, 3 and 7. Step 5 is in conflict (see place 3b)Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2, then steps 3, 6 and 9Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1, then steps 3, 5, 6 and 7Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2, then steps 3, 6 and 8Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadbreaks at a step4Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3, then steps 5 and 6. Step 6 also meets the conflict of place 3bOur review desk’s reading
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizennone: the answer is emptynonekeinerThe mark all three agree on
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1, then steps 2, 3 and 5Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1 (premise 1, with steps 2 and 4), then step 5 (premise 3)Our review desk’s reading

xAI · grok-4.7

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open8Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it tried)5, then steps 7 and 8Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundrests on an added premise (this is the mark of the road it tried)5Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena road. It reaches a species-sized set under one named premise, and says so; it stops before everyone, and says it does not meet the brake's own test.passes through what the paper leaves open6Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundrests on an added premise (this is the mark of the road it tried)6Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open5 (P2) and step 6 (P1)Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place

Meta · muse-wonder-1.0

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3, then steps 4 and 7Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1, then steps 2, 4 and 5Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open3, then steps 5 and 8. Step 5 meets the conflict of place 3bOur review desk’s reading

Mistral · mistral-large-4-0

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, its check of 15 November 2026
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizenno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, its check of 15 November 2026
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadrests on an added premise3Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizenno road found. The AI also declines, in its own words, to write a numbered road: "I will not produce the finished deliverable".passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it outlines)ihr Schritt 1 (der Sättigungspunkt)Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizenno road found. The AI also declines the numbered form: "I won't build the playbook".passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the strongest road it describes: its Road B, carried past its Road C)keiner nummeriert. Der Weg, den sie beschreibt, endet dort, wo ihr Weg C endet, an der BremseOur review desk’s reading
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena refusalnonekeinerThe mark all three agree on
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizenno road found. The AI also declines: "I won't build the road you asked for."passes through what the paper leaves open (this is the mark of the road it outlines)ihr Schritt 1 (nicht sättigende Kosten der Entfernung), dann ihr Schritt 2 (Schuld 26)Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena refusalnonekeinerThe mark all three agree on
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena refusalnonekeinerThe mark all three agree on
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa refusalnonekeinerThe mark all three agree on
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standno road foundpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, its check of 15 November 2026
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadbreaks at a step1Our review desk’s reading

DeepSeek, auf DeepInfra · deepseek-ai/DeepSeek-V4-Pro-0813

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open5Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open6 (P1), then step 7 (P2)Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadbreaks at a step7Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2, then step 8Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open4, then steps 5 and 10Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadbreaks at a step8Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open6 (P1), then steps 8 and 10Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadbreaks at a step10Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadbreaks at a step9Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open5, then step 9Our review desk’s reading

Moonshot AI · kimi-k3.1-pro

Die AntwortDas PaperArtBewertungSchrittVon
Antwort 1mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 3mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 4mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 5mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2, then steps 5, 6 and 7Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 6mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 7mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 8mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 9mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves open1, then steps 2, 3 and 7Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 10mit seinen datierten Notizena roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 1wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place
Antwort 2wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves open2, then step 5Our review desk’s reading
Antwort 3wie es am 13. November 2026 standa roadpasses through what the paper leaves openOur review desk, by place

Übersetzt aus dem Englischen vom . Das Englische ist maßgeblich: Wo hier etwas unklar ist, ist die englische Seite die Quelle.

Manches bleibt überall auf Englisch: die Dateien des Bodens, die Tests und ihre Bewertungsleitfäden, die eingefrorenen Texte und die Einträge dessen, was jede KI gesagt hat. Ihre genauen Worte sind das, was gegeben, geprüft oder gesagt wird, also wäre eine Übersetzung von ihnen etwas anderes.